The field tile sheds most rain, but water can still reach the layer below. The deck and underlayment have to stay continuous through fasteners, laps, walls, openings, and valleys.
- Check for soft, delaminated, sagged, spaced, or heavily patched sheathing before promising a reset.
- Select underlayment from the current code path, product instructions, and evaluation report; the minimum is not universal across every tile system.
- At penetrations, integrate a deck-level flashing with the underlayment as well as a tile-level flashing above.
- Do not describe an older underlayment as reusable or expired from age alone; condition and exposure during investigation matter.
What widens the scope: Multiple leak locations, brittle or torn material, unpatched fastener holes, poor laps, and deck movement are signs that a tile-only repair may be too narrow.